I have an absolutely bizarre desire to download all of these, and then rip them apart, scene by scene, and then estimate pose, facial pose, gender, etc. Do facial recognition, so I know where the same actor is in all of the scenes...
And then to take a movie like The Matrix, or Star Wars, and then recreate it, shot for shot, as closely as I can, using clips from Public Domain movies.
Especially if I can pick, like, "this actor in this public domain movie, or movies, would be a good Neo, or Luke." And it turns out that he's in enough shots, and poses, that I'm able to remake all of that character's scenes, from Public Domain footage of this other actor.
This would be cool, but if you think that you're somehow getting around copyright law, I'm pretty sure the result would still be a derivative work of the film you're recreating.
This feels just a few steps removed from bringing the technology from the 1990 film "Total Recall" to life. Clients are able to purchase completely custom memories, choosing the exact characters that will appear in their "vacations", their ages, and appearances.
I'm also kind of reminded of A Scanner Darkly. That would be another interesting movie to reconstruct this way.
I'm also reminded of those posters in the mall, where from a distance, it's an actor's face. But when you walk up close, it's actually made of hundreds of stills from their films.
The project is neat, but HN might be more interested in the experimental front end for it at https://wikiflix.toolforge.org/#/, which is buried somewhat as a link on the page.
That frontend seems to have things that aren't hosted on Wikimedia Commons, whereas I think OP's link is Wikimedia-exclusive and more reliable.
For example, Network (1976) - one of my favourite films - isn't listed on the Wikimedia page, but it's listed on the WikiFlix frontend. I was a little surprised to see that, since AFAIK it's still under copyright. Clicking through, it's trying to embed a copy from the Internet Archive, from which it was taken down because, yes, it's still under copyright.
> The WikiFlix tool is hosted on Toolforge in the US. Toolforge is operated by the Wikimedia Foundation. All WikiFlix content is generated from Wikidata and maintained by that community.
I have an absolutely bizarre desire to download all of these, and then rip them apart, scene by scene, and then estimate pose, facial pose, gender, etc. Do facial recognition, so I know where the same actor is in all of the scenes...
And then to take a movie like The Matrix, or Star Wars, and then recreate it, shot for shot, as closely as I can, using clips from Public Domain movies.
Especially if I can pick, like, "this actor in this public domain movie, or movies, would be a good Neo, or Luke." And it turns out that he's in enough shots, and poses, that I'm able to remake all of that character's scenes, from Public Domain footage of this other actor.
I feel like you should check out https://youtu.be/5GFW-eEWXlc?si=w3KTUkIprSeBYH3f
Enjoy.
Also https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UaGAVp3Sgt8
Is this helpful?
Qwen3-VL can scan two-hour videos and pinpoint nearly every detail - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46094606 - December 2025
This would be cool, but if you think that you're somehow getting around copyright law, I'm pretty sure the result would still be a derivative work of the film you're recreating.
Right, but what if I just shared a script?
You start with a digital copy of the movie I'm starting from...
I extract the audio...
And then my script downloads the Public Domain movies...
...and I've got a hard-coded list of cuts to take from each of the Public Domain movies...
...and combine it with the movie audio?
My script is just a few hundred KB.
As long as the movie you start from is pretty well in audio synch with the version I start from...
Heck, I could probably even compensate for that, too... A little bit of analysis to listen for the first words spoken...
Just insist it's a parody
This feels just a few steps removed from bringing the technology from the 1990 film "Total Recall" to life. Clients are able to purchase completely custom memories, choosing the exact characters that will appear in their "vacations", their ages, and appearances.
I'm also kind of reminded of A Scanner Darkly. That would be another interesting movie to reconstruct this way.
I'm also reminded of those posters in the mall, where from a distance, it's an actor's face. But when you walk up close, it's actually made of hundreds of stills from their films.
That would be really interesting if you have enough ML knowledge to do it !
Well, with things like this, I feel like someone could get interesting results pretty quickly:
https://lintangwisesa.github.io/MediaPipe-in-JavaScript/inde...
https://github.com/cosyneco/MediaPipe.NET
https://ai.google.dev/edge/mediapipe/solutions/guide
I'd think you'd start with a tool to automatically cut video into scenes, and kind of go from there...
Please do, and let us know when it is finished so that we can all watch it.
The project is neat, but HN might be more interested in the experimental front end for it at https://wikiflix.toolforge.org/#/, which is buried somewhat as a link on the page.
That frontend seems to have things that aren't hosted on Wikimedia Commons, whereas I think OP's link is Wikimedia-exclusive and more reliable.
For example, Network (1976) - one of my favourite films - isn't listed on the Wikimedia page, but it's listed on the WikiFlix frontend. I was a little surprised to see that, since AFAIK it's still under copyright. Clicking through, it's trying to embed a copy from the Internet Archive, from which it was taken down because, yes, it's still under copyright.
> The WikiFlix tool is hosted on Toolforge in the US. Toolforge is operated by the Wikimedia Foundation. All WikiFlix content is generated from Wikidata and maintained by that community.
https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Help:WikiFlix
Network's WikiData entry is https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q572165, which includes the Archive link and lacks a copyright status. This is also linked to from the barcode icon at the top of the movie's WikiFlix page: https://wikiflix.toolforge.org/#/entry/572165
Took about 2 minutes with no prior experience to remove the dead IA link and add the copyright status attribute to the WikiData item.
It's no longer accessible. It might be a regional thing, if you can still see it?
It's missing Santa Claus Conquers the Martians.
It's there: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Santa_Claus_Conq...
Why not use peertube software?